Tag: Zhang Liang

Comprehensive Reflections to Aid in Governance

By Sima Guang

Translated By Yiming Yang 

Annals of Han Book 3 Scroll 11

Duration of 3 years

The 5th year of the Emperor Gaozu (202 B.C.)

In October of that winter, the King of Han pursued King Xiang Yu to Guling. He arranged a meeting with Han Xin, the King of Qi, and Peng Yue, the Prime Minister of Wei, to plan an assault on the army of Chu. However, Han Xin and Peng Yue did not attend. King Xiang Yu struck back at the Han forces and dealt them a severe blow. The Han troops retreated to their camps and refused to engage further.

The King of Han asked Zhang Liang, “What should we do now that our allies haven’t come to our aid?”

Zhang Liang replied, “The Kingdom of Chu is on the verge of collapse, but these two generals haven’t yet secured their territories. Their absence was to be expected. If Your Majesty is willing to share the land, they will come at once. The enthronement of Han Xin as King of Qi was not your original intent, and he is aware of that and not convinced of your trust. Peng Yue conquered the lands of Wei, yet Your Majesty only appointed him Prime Minister due to the presence of Wei Bao. Now that Wei Bao is dead, Peng Yue expects to be enthroned, but Your Majesty has hesitated.”

“If Your Majesty grants the land from Suiyang county to the north, up to Gucheng, as Peng Yue‘s kingdom, and makes him king; and if you give the land from ancient State of Chen to the east, all the way to the East Ocean, to Han Xin, the King of Qi, they will join us immediately. Han Xin‘s home is in the Kingdom of Chu, and his intention would be to reclaim it. If Your Majesty cedes these lands and gives them authority to manage their battles, the downfall of Chu will not be difficult.”

The King of Han followed Zhang Liang’s advice, and Han Xin and Peng Yue soon led their troops to join him, as expected.

In November, General Liu Jia crossed the Huai River to the south and laid siege to the city of Shouchun. He sent an emissary to persuade King Xiang Yu’s Grand Marshal, Zhou Yin, to defect. Zhou Yin betrayed the Kingdom of Chu and led troops from Shu county in a massacre in Lu county. He then organized the soldiers of Jiujiang to welcome their former king, Qingbu. Afterward, he moved to Chengfu county, where he carried out another massacre before joining forces with General Liu Jia.

In December, King Xiang Yu reached Gaixia. His army had dwindled, and they were running out of food. All his battles against the Han forces had ended in failure, and they were now trapped in bastions. The Han army, along with allied forces, surrounded his camps in multiple layers. One night, King Xiang Yu heard folk songs of Chu being sung by the Han soldiers from all sides. Astonished, he exclaimed, “Has the Han army taken over all of Chu? Why are so many Chu folks here?” He rose, drank liquor in his tent, and, overcome with emotion, began singing sorrowful songs, tears streaming down his face. Those around him sobbed, not daring to look at him.

That night, King Xiang Yu mounted his favorite steed, named Zhui, and led 800 elite cavalrymen to break through the encirclement. They rode south at high speed, and it was not until dawn that the Han army realized they had fled. General Guan Ying was ordered to pursue them with 5,000 cavalrymen. King Xiang Yu managed to cross the Huai River, but by then, only about a hundred cavalrymen remained with him. They became lost near Yinling town and asked a farmer for directions. The farmer said, “Turn left.” They followed his advice and were soon trapped in a large swamp, where the Han cavalry caught up with them.

King Xiang Yu fled east again and reached Dongcheng county with only 28 cavalrymen remaining. Several thousand Han cavalry were in pursuit. Realizing he could not escape, Xiang Yu spoke to his followers: “It has been eight years since I took up arms. I have fought more than seventy battles and never been defeated. That is why I am the hegemon of the land. Yet, now we are besieged. This is the will of Heaven, not my failure as a warrior. In this final duel of life and death, I want to fight for sport and claim at least three victories: breaking the encirclement, beheading an enemy commander, and cutting down their banner. I want to prove to you that it is Heaven’s will, not my own shortcomings, that has doomed us.”

He divided his riders into four groups, each facing a different direction, as the Han cavalry encircled them in multiple layers. Xiang Yu told his followers, “I will take out one of their commanders for you.” He then ordered them to charge in all four directions and regroup at three points over the mountain to the east. Xiang Yu roared as he charged into the Han formation, causing their soldiers to panic and flee. He beheaded a Han commander in the chaos.

A Han cavalry court guard named Yang Xi pursued Xiang Yu, but when Xiang Yu turned and stared at him with a thunderous shout, both Yang Xi and his horse were so terrified that they retreated several miles before recovering their nerve.

Xiang Yu met his followers at the three rendezvous points. The Han pursuers, unsure where he was, split their forces into three groups to surround each location. Xiang Yu charged the Han troops once more, beheading another commander and killing dozens of Han soldiers. When the group regrouped again, only two horsemen were missing.

Xiang Yu asked his followers, “How was that?”

His men, filled with admiration, dismounted and said, “Exactly as Your Majesty said!”

King Xiang Yu planned to cross the Yangtze River at the town of Wujiang, where the post chief of Wujiang ford had prepared a boat for him. The chief urged him, “Jiangdong region may not be large, but it covers thousands of miles and has a population in the hundreds of thousands. It is enough for Your Majesty to reclaim power. Please cross quickly—only I have boats, and the Han soldiers won’t be able to follow.”

Xiang Yu laughed and reconsidered: “Why should I cross the river if Heaven has already doomed me? I, Xiang Ji, crossed this river with 8,000 sons of Jiangdong and launched my western campaign. Today, not one of them returned with me. Even if the people of Jiangdong still love me and make me their king, I don’t have the heart to face them again! They may not say a word, but how could I not feel ashamed?”

He gave his horse, Zhui, as a gift to the post chief and ordered his guards to dismount for one final battle. Xiang Yu fought hand-to-hand with a sword, killing hundreds of Han soldiers on his own, though he was wounded in more than ten places.

During the fight, Xiang Yu saw a cavalry major, Lü Matong, and asked, “Aren’t you an old friend of mine?” Lü Matong dared not face Xiang Yu, turned to calvary court guard Wang Yi, and pointed to the king, “This is King Xiang Yu!”

Xiang Yu responded, “I’ve heard the Kingdom of Han has offered 1,000 ounces of gold and a fief of 10,000 households for my head. I’ll repay you a favor for your kindness.” With that, he slashed his own throat.

Wang Yi took Xiang Yu’s head, but chaos erupted as Han cavalrymen trampled each other, each trying to claim a piece of Xiang Yu’s body. In the mayhem, dozens of soldiers died. Ultimately, five men—Yang Xi, Lü Matong, Lü Sheng, Yang Wu, and Wang Yi—each claimed a piece of Xiang Yu. Together, they confirmed the remains and received the reward. Each was given a fief of 2,000 households and the title of marquis.

All the cities of the Kingdom of Chu had surrendered to Han rule, except for the county of Lu. The King of Han led the army of the entire country to attack the city. As they approached the city walls, they heard chanting and music from within. The King of Han realized that this was Xiang Yu’s fiefdom, and the people of Lu remained defiant because of their loyalty to him and adherence to the rites.

The King of Han then showed Xiang Yu‘s severed head to the people of Lu, and the city capitulated. He ordered that Xiang Yu‘s funeral be conducted in the name of the Duke of Lu and had him buried in Gucheng county. The King of Han attended the ceremony himself and wept at the altar. He pardoned all members of the Xiang family, granting Xiang Bo and three others the title of marquis and the surname Liu. Additionally, he allowed those who had been forcibly relocated to Chu to return to their original homes.

The great historian Sima Qian once commented: Xiang Yu rose from obscurity and dismantled the Qin Empire with the help of five allied monarchs in just three years. He divided the land and granted his followers the titles of king and marquis, becoming the de facto ruler of the country. Although his reign ended poorly, his achievements were nonetheless remarkable in history. Yearning for his home state of Chu, he abandoned the strategic region of Guanzhong. He exiled the honorary emperor and usurped power. Given this, it is difficult to fault the kings and marquises he elevated, who later turned against him. Xiang Yu was overly confident in his military prowess and trusted his own judgment, often deviating from established norms. He sought hegemony and ambitious control but relied solely on brute force to govern. He ultimately perished in the east, and his kingdom was destroyed. Even in defeat, he refused to acknowledge his faults, blaming his downfall on fate, claiming, “It was Heaven that doomed me, not my military failure.” How absurd!

In his Exemplary Sayings, Yang Xiong commented: Someone asked, “The King of Chu failed at Gaixia. Before his death, he claimed it was Heaven’s will. Does that make sense?” The answer was: “The King of Han sought advice from many, and more ideas overcame more brute force. The King of Chu, on the other hand, discouraged counsel and weakened his own position. Victory goes to those who triumph through wisdom. Defeat comes to those who undermine themselves. What does Heaven have to do with it?”