Comprehensive Reflections to Aid in Governance
By Sima Guang
Translated By Yiming Yang
Annals of Han Book 24 Scroll 32 (continued)
The 1st year of Emperor Cheng’s Suihe Era (8 B.C.)
In the first month of spring, a general amnesty was proclaimed throughout the empire.
The Emperor summoned the Chancellor Zhai Fangjin, Grand Master of the Censorate Kong Guang, General of the Right Lian Bao, and General of the Rear Zhu Bo to the inner court to deliberate on the selection of an heir between the Prince of Zhongshan and the Prince of Dingtao. Zhai Fangjin, Wang Gen, Lian Bao, and Zhu Bo all held that “the Prince of Dingtao, Liu Xin, is the son of the Emperor’s younger brother. The Book of Rites states: ‘The son of a brother is as one’s own son; when established as heir, he becomes imperial son.’ Therefore, the Prince of Dingtao ought to be named heir.”
Kong Guang alone dissented, arguing: “The Rites give precedence to closeness of kinship in establishing an heir. The Book of Documents, in the chapter Pan Geng, records that during the Shang dynasty succession passed from elder brother to younger brother. The Prince of Zhongshan is the son of the late Emperor and the Emperor’s own younger brother; he should therefore be the heir.”
The Emperor rejected Kong Guang’s view, stating that “the Prince of Zhongshan lacks capability; moreover, according to the Rites, brothers may not enter the same ancestral temple.” Accordingly, on February 9, an edict was issued appointing the Prince of Dingtao, Liu Xin, as Crown Prince. Feng Shen, the affinal uncle and Grand Master of Remonstration of the Prince of Zhongshan, was enfeoffed as Marquis of Yixiang, and the Zhongshan princedom was augmented by thirty thousand households as compensation.
The Bearer of the Mace, Ren Hong, was appointed Grand Herald and dispatched to summon the Prince of Dingtao. Liu Xin submitted a memorial expressing reluctance, saying: “I lack the competency and virtue required for the position of Crown Prince. I wish to remain in the residence of the Prince of Dingtao in the capital, attending daily upon the court and awaiting the birth of a worthy heir, after which I may return to my princedom and serve as a vassal.” The memorial was presented to the Emperor, who took note of it.
On February 14, Kong Guang was demoted to Minister of Justice for opposing the decision on the heir, and He Wu was appointed Grand Master of the Censorate.
Earlier, an edict had sought descendants of the Yin (Shang) dynasty, but those descendants were found to have split into more than ten surnames, and the direct line of succession could not be determined. Kuang Heng and Mei Fu both proposed that the descendants of Confucius be appointed as successors to the Yin dynasty. The Emperor approved and granted Kong Ji the title of Marquis Shaojia of Yin. In March, Kong Ji and the Marquis Chengxiu of Zhou, were both elevated to the rank of duke, each receiving a fief one hundred li in extent.
The Emperor visited Yong and performed sacrifices at the Five-Deity Altar.
While serving as Minister of Justice, He Wu submitted a proposal, stating: “The decline of customs and the increasing complexity of government affairs mean that present-day chancellors cannot compare with those of antiquity. The Chancellor alone now manages the affairs of the three highest offices, which is why state business has long been neglected and left unresolved. The Three Excellencies should be reestablished.” The Emperor agreed.
In April of summer, the Emperor bestowed the seal of the Grand Marshal upon Wang Gen, Marquis of Quyang, and established a public office for him, while abolishing the post of General of Agile Cavalry. He appointed He Wu, Grand Master of the Censorate, as Grand Excellency of Works and enfeoffed him as Marquis of Fanxiang. These offices were accorded honors equivalent to those of the chancellery, thus constituting the three highest offices.
In autumn, on August 8, Liu Xing, Prince of Zhongshan, died.
Xiongnu Juya Chanyu also died. His younger brother Nangzhiyasi succeeded him as Wuzhuliu Ruodi Chanyu. Wuzhuliu Chanyu appointed his younger brother Yue as Left Tuqi King and Yu as Right Tuqi King. The Han dispatched General of the Household Xiahou Fan and Lieutenant Colonel Han Rong as envoys to the Xiongnu.
Someone informed Wang Gen: “There is a tract of Xiongnu land wedged deep into Han territory, extending as far as Zhangye Commandery. It produces distinctive resources, such as timber suitable for arrows and eagle feathers. If this land were obtained, it would greatly benefit the frontier: the state would gain abundant resources, expand its territory, and the general’s reputation would be enhanced without limit.”
Wang Gen relayed this proposal to the Emperor, who was inclined to request the land directly from the Chanyu. However, fearing that a refusal might undermine imperial authority and damage the Emperor’s prestige, Wang Gen disclosed the Emperor’s intention to Xiahou Fan and instructed him to present the request as his own initiative. When Xiahou Fan reached the Xiongnu court, he addressed Wuzhuliu Chanyu, saying: “I have observed that the Xiongnu possess land that intrudes into Han territory as far as Zhangye Commandery. The Han maintain three commandant posts along the frontier, with hundreds of soldiers enduring cold and hardship and suffering prolonged exhaustion. The Chanyu should submit a letter offering this land, straightening the boundary. This would reduce the burden on the commandants and troops, repay the Emperor’s favor, and the recompense from Han would surely be generous.”
Wuzhuliu Chanyu asked, “Is this an imperial edict, or merely a request from the ambassador?”
Xiahou Fan replied, “It reflects the intent of an edict, though I am also presenting it here as a proposal for the Chanyu’s consideration.”
The Chanyu said, “This land is occupied by King Wenyutu. We are not fully aware of its extent or resources. Let me dispatch a man to inquire into it.”
Xiahou Fan and Han Rong returned to Han. Later, they were again sent as envoys to the Xiongnu and renewed the request for the land.
The Chanyu responded: “Our ancestors have held this land for five generations. The Han never sought it before—why do they do so now? I have already consulted King Wenyutu. The western vassals of the Xiongnu built their yurts and carts from the timber of this mountain, and it was also land of my late father, which we dare not relinquish.”
Xiahou Fan returned and was demoted to Prefect of Taiyuan. Wuzhuliu Chanyu sent a letter to the Han detailing Xiahou Fan’s request for the land. An imperial edict replied to the Chanyu: “Xiahou Fan falsely claimed the intent of an edict in requesting land from the Chanyu, an offense punishable by death. However, in light of two recent general amnesties, he has been reassigned as Prefect of Jinan and is henceforth forbidden from ever going to the Xiongnu.”
In winter, on October 14, Wang Gen fell ill and was relieved of his duties.
Since the Crown Prince, Liu Xin, had already been adopted as the Emperor’s heir, he could no longer attend to the sacrifices of his own forefathers. In November, the Emperor therefore appointed Liu Jing, grandson of the Prince of Chu, as Prince of Dingtao, to continue the lineage of Liu Kang, Prince Gong of Dingtao. The Crown Prince wished to present his gratitude by genuflection. The Junior Tutor, Yan Chong, argued: “According to the rites, one who has been adopted as heir may not attend to private kinship, nor is it proper for him to offer genuflection.” The Grand Tutor, Zhao Xuan, held that genuflection to one’s father should be allowed, and the Crown Prince agreed with him. An edict was issued to inquire into the grounds for this open expression of gratitude. The Minister of the State Secretariat submitted a memorial impeaching Zhao Xuan, and the Emperor demoted him to Privy Treasurer; the Chamberlain Shi Dan was appointed Grand Tutor in his place.
When the Crown Prince was young, his grandmother, Queen Dowager Fu, personally raised and cared for him. After he was established as Crown Prince, an edict directed that Queen Dowager Fu and the Crown Prince’s mother, Consort Ding, should reside separately at the Dingtao official lodge in the capital and not see him regularly. After some time, Empress Dowager Wang proposed that Queen Dowager Fu and Consort Ding be allowed to visit the Crown Prince’s palace once every ten days. The Emperor replied: “The Crown Prince is the heir to the throne and should serve Your Majesty together with us; he should not attend to private relatives.”
Empress Dowager Wang said: “The Crown Prince was small, and Queen Dowager Fu raised him. Now, visiting the Crown Prince’s residence is merely an expression of affection from his nurse and does not constitute impropriety.” Accordingly, Queen Dowager Fu was permitted to visit the Crown Prince’s palace, while Consort Ding, who had not raised him, was not allowed to do so.